Protein dynamics from NMR: The slowly relaxing local structure analysis compared with model-free analysis

¹⁵N ^-1H spin relaxation is a powerful method for deriving information on protein dynamics. The traditional method of data analysis is model-free (MF), where the global and local N - H motions are independent and the local geometry is simplified. The common MF analysis consists of fitting single-field data. The results are typically field-dependent, and multifield data cannot be fit with standard fitting schemes. Cases where known functional dynamics has not been detected by MF were identified by us and others. Recently we applied to spin relaxation in proteins the slowly relaxing local structure (SRLS) approach, which accounts rigorously for mode mixing and general features of local geometry. SRLS was shown to yield MF in appropriate asymptotic limits. We found that the experimental spectral density corresponds quite well to the SRLS spectral density. The MF formulas are often used outside of their validity ranges, allowing small data sets to be force-fitted with good statistics but inaccurate best-fit parameters. This paper focuses on the mechanism of force-fitting and its implications. It is shown that MF analysis force-fits the experimental data because mode mixing, the rhombic symmetry of the local ordering and general features of local geometry are not accounted for. Combined multifield multitemperature data analyzed with the MF approach may lead to the detection of incorrect phenomena, and conformational entropy derived from MF order parameters may be highly inaccurate. On the other hand, fitting to more appropriate models can yield consistent physically insightful information. This requires that the complexity of the theoretical spectral densities matches the integrity of the experimental data. As shown herein, the SRLS spectral densities comply with this requirement.