Clonal expansion and not cell interconversion is the basis for the neuroblast and nonneuronal types of the SK-N-SH neuroblastoma cell line

The ability of neuroblastoma (NB) cells to interconvert bidirectionally, in vitro, from a neuroblast (N) to a nonneuronal (S) form is a well-studied biologic phenomenon of great clinical importance. Differences in the morphologic/ biochemical characteristics and gene expression patterns of the two cell populations have been investigated extensively in an effort to unravel the transdifferentiation process. Subcloning of the SK-N-SH NB cell line has led to two morphologically distinct cell types: SH-SY5Y (N-type) and SH-EP (S-type). Karyotypic analysis combined with G-banding and SKY showed a difference between these two cell types in the copy number of the 2p15∼pter segment, including the MYC-N gene. FISH analysis showed an extra copy of MYC-N present in all three lines: in SK-N-SH and SH-SY5Y the majority of cells had three copies of MYC-N, whereas in SH-EP the majority had two copies and only a small cell population with three copies was present. We suggest that the simultaneous coexistence of both cell types and the subsequent clonal expansion of one over the other is a possible explanation for the phenomenon observed and not the accepted interconversion model. According to the clonal expansion model, both N and S cells are simultaneously present in both cell lines. Under certain conditions, the less-aggressive S cells can dominate over the highly aggressive N cells, which eventually lead to the formation of the SH-EP and vice-versa.